Someone proves 1=3 by subtracting 2 to get -1=1, then squaring to obtain the true statement 1=1. What exactly is wrong?
Quant ResearchLevel: IntermediateNoninvertible transformations
Someone proves 1=3 by subtracting 2 to get -1=1, then squaring to obtain the true statement 1=1. What exactly is wrong?
Hints
- Track the direction of every logical arrow.
- Ask whether squaring can be undone uniquely.
Answer
They proved that the proposed statement implies a truth, not that the truth implies the statement. Squaring is not injective: -1 and 1 square equally without being equal. Reverse steps require equivalence, not one-way implication.
Source and licence: Oscar Levin — Discrete Mathematics: An Open Introduction, 3rd edition · CC-BY-SA-4.0 · answer: Quantoros editorial