Skip to content
Quantoros

A reporter makes three claims: P or S; if S then Q; if P or Q then R. Either all claims are true or all false. Which…

Quant ResearchLevel: IntermediateTruth-teller constraints

A reporter makes three claims: P or S; if S then Q; if P or Q then R. Either all claims are true or all false. Which case holds, and must R hold?

Hints
  • Try making the first two claims false together.
  • Chain the implications after resolving truthfulness.

Answer

All false is impossible: false P or S makes S false, so S implies Q would be true. Hence all are true. P or S holds; if S, then Q, so P or Q holds either way. Therefore R is true.

Source and licence: Oscar Levin — Discrete Mathematics: An Open Introduction, 3rd edition · CC-BY-SA-4.0 · answer: Quantoros editorial

Related questions