Can A be independent of B and B independent of C while A and C are dependent? Give a concrete fair-coin example.
Quant ResearchLevel: IntermediateNontransitive independence
Can A be independent of B and B independent of C while A and C are dependent? Give a concrete fair-coin example.
Hints
- You are allowed to choose C equal to A.
- A nontrivial event is not independent of itself.
Answer
Use two independent fair bits X,Y. Let A={X=1}, B={Y=1}, C=A. The first two pairs are independent, but P(A∩C)=1/2 != P(A)P(C)=1/4. Independence is not transitive.
Source and licence: Lehman, Leighton & Meyer — Mathematics for Computer Science (2018-06-06) · CC-BY-SA-3.0 · answer: Quantoros editorial